The Pandemic Has Produced a Radical Experiment in Federalism

Source: Reason - View Original Article
Published: May 03, 2020
Category:
Bias Rating:

53% Conservative


Bias Score Calculation:


Policies:

Death Penalty

Sentiments

98% " The same applies today, perhaps more than ever.""
97% "The result is what The New York Times calls a patchwork approach, in which different states make different choices about how to proceed.""
95% "That disparity probably has something to do with when social distancing began in each place, but it also reflects New York City's unique structural ..."
91% "Denser urban areas may be willing to accept more control.""
90% "And we may all benefit from seeing the results of a variety of approaches to balancing economic and public health goals.""
89% "The outbreak has produced a reminder of federalism's essential value: In a country as large as the United States, different localities are going to ..."
86% "The information from these state-based experiments will necessarily be imperfect and subject to broad interpretation, because each state is different.""
85% "A patchwork approach is almost certainly what we need.""
84% "It is not just highly populated but dense, and it relies on public transit more than any other U.S. city.""
82% "But states are making their own decisions.""

We have listed the top 10 sentiments. More sentiments do exist. Please review the full article for more information.



*Our bias meter rating uses data science including sentiment analysis, machine learning and our proprietary algorithm for determining biases in news articles. The rating is an independent analysis and is not affiliated nor sponsored by the news source or any other organization

Extremely
Liberal

Very
Liberal

Moderate-left

Neutral

Moderate-right

Very
Conservative

Extremely
Conservative

100%

100%

Contributing sentiments towards policy:

98% : " The same applies today, perhaps more than ever.
97% : The result is what The New York Times calls a "patchwork" approach, in which different states make different choices about how to proceed.
95% : That disparity probably has something to do with when social distancing began in each place, but it also reflects New York City's unique structural attributes.
91% : Denser urban areas may be willing to accept more control.
90% : And we may all benefit from seeing the results of a variety of approaches to balancing economic and public health goals.
89% : The outbreak has produced a reminder of federalism's essential value: In a country as large as the United States, different localities are going to have different needs.
86% : The information from these state-based experiments will necessarily be imperfect and subject to broad interpretation, because each state is different.
85% : A patchwork approach is almost certainly what we need.
84% : It is not just highly populated but dense, and it relies on public transit more than any other U.S. city.
82% : But states are making their own decisions.
81% : That's good.
81% : By the middle of April, New York had 14 times as many deaths as California.
81% : It's true, of course, that the national response under Trump has often been lacking: The president has failed to set priorities within his own administration, and he has failed to deliver a clear and consistent message to the nation about the response and what to expect.
80% : The state of Georgia has come in for criticism for moving faster to reopen than other states.
80% : Many of those differences are medical.
79% : The effect of temperature on the virus continues to be debated as well.
75% : In terms of infections and deaths, the difference between New York City and nearly everywhere else is stark.
75% : The federalist approach means the country is not completely hamstrung by bumbling federal bureaucracy and a hapless president.
74% : In fact, precisely the opposite is true: The states, not the president, get to make those calls.
74% : Anthony Fauci, the point person for the federal response to the pandemic, said this week that although state governors, mayors, and other local officials know their own areas best, "you want to give them a little wiggle room" -- but added, "my recommendation is, you know, don't wiggle too much."
68% : A little more than two weeks ago, President Donald Trump earned broad condemnation by declaring he has the "total" authority to determine when states reopen their economies.
67% : Varying state responses will provide the thing we need most right now: information.
67% : In particular, information about what happens when differing levels of economic restriction are applied.
66% : I say probably, because one of the problems facing policy makers right now is that there's still much we don't know about the virus, how it spreads, and how it eventually kills.
66% : (Have you heard of "COVID toe"?)
65% : A handful are reopening segments of their economies, with the details varying from state to state, and others are preparing to do so in the coming weeks.
63% : Even among dense, coastal blue states, there are large differences in outcomes.
56% : And that's how it should be.
53% : Critics have pointed to more centralized measures in other countries and wondered why America can't do the same.
53% : These federal failures -- of leadership, of planning, of execution, of communication -- are another reason to be glad that the most important locus of control is at the state level.
52% : As the White House waffled on closure guidelines in March, former Maryland Gov. Martin O'Malley called the federal response a "Darwinian approach to federalism.
51% : But it will give us tools to keep improving our ability to make better, smarter, more tailored decisions.
49% : State leaders might gripe about the lack of direction from the White House, but there are political opportunities for them as well.
48% : Several states have formed explicit compacts, essentially working groups to coordinate their own responses.
47% : The varying responses should also provide something we desperately need: information.
46% : The Food and Drug Administration (FDA) and the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention made catastrophic early decisions, and at times federal authorities have even blocked state-level efforts, such as when the FDA initially refused to expand a cap on facemask decontamination in Ohio.
45% : There are ongoing questions about how the virus is passed from person to person, with some speculation that it might be exacerbated by air conditioning.
45% : "It is one of the happy incidents of the federal system," Justice Louis D. Brandeis famously wrote in 1932, "that a single courageous state may, if its citizens choose, serve as a laboratory; and try novel social and economic experiments without risk to the rest of the country.
43% : And then there are political considerations: Even beyond the unfortunate way that the pandemic has been subsumed into the left-right culture wars, there are meaningful differences in what different parts of the country want, and will accept, in terms of economic restrictions.
42% : A single point of control is also a single point of failure.
41% : Even the list of symptoms seems to be growing.
36% : And several governors, including the Ohio Republican Mike DeWine and the New York Democrat Andrew Cuomo, have risen in popularity and profile, in part by bucking Trump.
35% : In the face of such persistent uncertainty about the basic mechanisms for transmission and infection, we're best off with a multiplicity of responses, one that assumes there's no single right answer, or at least no obvious one, because too many essential facts remain unknown.
31% : Those sorts of decisions are what federalism enables, and arguably more than anything else, they are what we need right now.
30% : New York Gov. Andrew Cuomo has complained that the president "has to put forth a model.
25% : Yet concerns about Trump's assertion of unlimited executive control have sometimes been paired with an opposing concern: that there is not enough centralization, that the federal government is refusing to take charge, that Trump should step up and do more.
23% : More rural, less populous states are likely to have less tolerance for extended lockdowns.
19% : (Indeed, a few states never imposed stay-at-home orders at all.)
18% : That's decisions -- plural, not singular.

*Our bias meter rating uses data science including sentiment analysis, machine learning and our proprietary algorithm for determining biases in news articles. The rating is an independent analysis and is not affiliated nor sponsored by the news source or any other organization

Share via
Copy link
Powered by Social Snap