The Guardian view on immigration and Covid-19: old myths are exposed | Editorial

Source: The Guardian - View Original Article
Published: Apr 30, 2020
Category:
Bias Rating:

81% Liberal


Bias Score Calculation:


Policies:

Welfare

Sentiments

94% "Fallacies and prejudices that have informed UK policy for a generation are being exposed by the current crisis.""
93% "That was the target adopted by David Cameron in 2010 and pursued aggressively by Theresa May at the Home Office and in Downing Street.""
89% "The promise to take back control of borders had strong emotional appeal, but was never rooted in the reality of modern Britain, where migrants ..."
88% "The distinction is meant to favour what ministers call the best and brightest while deterring those whom decades of political rhetoric have cast as ..."
81% "Immigrants have kept public transport running, delivered goods and, most poignantly, kept the NHS and social care services operational.""
78% "That awkward fact was always bound to emerge over time, but it has been revealed abruptly by the pandemic. Farmers are already warning that fruit ..."
70% "It would be shameful if the heroic contribution and sacrifices made by immigrants in these difficult times were met with callous ingratitude by the ..."
68% "Many immigrant workers, already in precarious employment or on visas that prohibit access to benefits, will suffer disproportionately from the economic impact of the ..."

We have listed the top 10 sentiments. More sentiments do exist. Please review the full article for more information.



*Our bias meter rating uses data science including sentiment analysis, machine learning and our proprietary algorithm for determining biases in news articles. The rating is an independent analysis and is not affiliated nor sponsored by the news source or any other organization

Extremely
Liberal

Very
Liberal

Moderate-left

Neutral

Moderate-right

Very
Conservative

Extremely
Conservative

100%

100%

Contributing sentiments towards policy:

94% : Fallacies and prejudices that have informed UK policy for a generation are being exposed by the current crisis.
93% : It has drastically cut labour migration.
93% : That was the target adopted by David Cameron in 2010 and pursued aggressively by Theresa May at the Home Office and in Downing Street.
89% : The promise to "take back control" of borders had strong emotional appeal, but was never rooted in the reality of modern Britain, where migrants of all skill levels and income brackets keep the economic and social wheels turning.
88% : The distinction is meant to favour what ministers call "the best and brightest" while deterring those whom decades of political rhetoric have cast as undesirable.
81% : Immigrants have kept public transport running, delivered goods and, most poignantly, kept the NHS and social care services operational.
78% : The charges against that latter group are various: poaching jobs from British-born citizens, depressing wages, failing to observe cultural norms and generally upsetting people with conspicuous otherness.
78% : That awkward fact was always bound to emerge over time, but it has been revealed abruptly by the pandemic. Farmers are already warning that fruit will rot in the fields without seasonal labour normally provided by EU citizens.
70% : It would be shameful if the heroic contribution and sacrifices made by immigrants in these difficult times were met with callous ingratitude by the government.
68% : Many immigrant workers, already in precarious employment or on visas that prohibit access to benefits, will suffer disproportionately from the economic impact of the pandemic.
67% : There is no longer an explicit commitment to make Britain a "hostile environment" for immigrants, but the apparatus of automatic suspicion and bureaucratic bullying developed under that rubric has not gone away.
64% : Lockdown prevents the gathering of real-time data, but it is a reasonable assumption when international travel has stopped that net migration is currently happening at a rate well below 100,000 per year.
63% : An appeal court this week upheld the law obliging landlords to check the immigration status of tenants, despite an earlier finding by the high court that the rules led to discrimination on racial grounds.
59% : The vilification reached its apogee in the campaign to take Britain out of the EU.
52% : Attempts to entice UK workers to fill the gap are failing.
44% : It was never met before being abandoned last year.
41% : There is no indication that ministers are reconsidering the new regime, which is based on a points system designed to select "skilled" workers over "unskilled" labour.
41% : It will not be easy to reverse that trend, but the opportunity is there if our politicians have the honesty and the courage to take it.
36% : They have put their lives at risk for a country that has been, at best, ambivalent about their entitlement to live here at all.
35% : This week would have seen the government's post-Brexit immigration bill return to the Commons, but the timetable has been discarded, not least because parliament's digital systems are not yet ready for remote voting.
32% : The debate has been oriented in entirely the wrong direction, with all the emphasis on a burden that should more rightly be understood as a blessing.
26% : The crisis has revealed how pointless and damaging it is for Britain to vilify immigrants who help keep the country afloat Covid-19 has accomplished in weeks something that UK governments spent a decade failing to do.
22% : What happens next is uncertain.

*Our bias meter rating uses data science including sentiment analysis, machine learning and our proprietary algorithm for determining biases in news articles. The rating is an independent analysis and is not affiliated nor sponsored by the news source or any other organization

Share via
Copy link
Powered by Social Snap