Opinion | Most Americans are now self-censoring. We're regressing.

Source: The Forward - View Original Article
Published: Jul 23, 2020
Category:
Bias Rating:

59% Liberal


Bias Score Calculation:

This article includes the following sentiments, providing an average bias score of 59% Liberal:

  • 1 positive sentiment for Anti-Discrimination Laws


Policies:

Anti-Discrimination Laws

Sentiments

  •   Liberal
  •   Neutral
95% "But that's the price of living in a messy but beautiful society with all kinds of people who disagree."
93% "We could, for example, see widespread pluralistic ignorance."
89% "Taken together, the implication of these results is that America is a place where most people are deeply worried about honestly engaging in the political process, something that could over time do real damage to our democracy."
86% "The survey found that 50 percent of strong liberals support firing a business executive who, in their personal capacity, donated to Donald Trump's re-election campaign."
78% "Yes, sometimes people will say things that upset or outrage us, and sometimes we will upset or outrage others."
76% "A new poll from the Cato Institute and YouGov suggests that this fear is widespread."
65% "In order to make things a little easier, it would be wise to heed the counsel of psychologist Jonathan Haidt, who says we should give less offense by being more polite and take less offense by charitably interpreting other's statements and offering forgiveness when we screw up."
55% "Pluralistic ignorance is a situation where members of a group may privately reject an idea, but they believe most of the other members of the group believe that idea, so they decide to accept it."
53% "One survey found that by 2014, for instance, the ratio of liberals to conservatives at American colleges and universities was six to one; among New England's institutions of higher education, it's 28 to one."
-51% "Even more worrying than the general climate of fear are the lengths with which some Americans are willing to go to punish their political opponents."
-52% "In fact, nearly every ideological grouping believes they have to self-censor, with 52 percent of liberals, 64 percent of moderates and 77 percent of conservatives agreeing that the current political climate prevents them from saying things they believe."
-61% "This sentiment is most common among Republicans, with 77 percent agreeing that they are fearful of sharing some of their political views, but majorities of Democrats (52 percent) and independents (59 percent) share the same view."
-72% "That last bit of information may be no surprise if you're familiar with some statistics about how liberal-leaning some American institutions have become."
-76% "Running an entire country on pluralistic ignorance would prevent us from addressing the actual concerns members of the public have."
-81% "Pinker is a rich and famous man who will likely escape any attempt at censorship thrown at him, but what should worry us more is the lowly graduate assistant or professor without tenure who worries that publishing an objective research finding will get them in hot water with their university if its results don't confirm the ideological priors of whatever group happens to be hegemonic in the culture."

We have listed the top 15 sentiments. More sentiments do exist. Please review the full article for more information.



*Our bias meter rating uses data science including sentiment analysis, machine learning and our proprietary algorithm for determining biases in news articles. The rating is an independent analysis and is not affiliated nor sponsored by the news source or any other organization

Extremely
Liberal

Very
Liberal

Moderate-left

Neutral

Moderate-right

Very
Conservative

Extremely
Conservative

100%

100%

Contributing sentiments towards policy:

95% : But that's the price of living in a messy but beautiful society with all kinds of people who disagree.
93% : We could, for example, see widespread "pluralistic ignorance.
89% : Taken together, the implication of these results is that America is a place where most people are deeply worried about honestly engaging in the political process, something that could over time do real damage to our democracy.
86% : The survey found that 50 percent of strong liberals support firing a business executive who, in their personal capacity, donated to Donald Trump's re-election campaign.
83% : This phenomenon is quite common on social media channels, where you're rewarded for conforming to group trends and punished for stepping outside the bounds of you cohort.
81% : 36 percent of strong conservatives, on the other hand, supported firing executives who donated to former vice president Joe Biden's current presidential campaign.
78% : Yes, sometimes people will say things that upset or outrage us, and sometimes we will upset or outrage others.
76% : It's common to hear anecdotes about friends or family who just don't feel comfortable discussing politics anymore.
76% : A new poll from the Cato Institute and YouGov suggests that this fear is widespread.
74% : It's hardly a surprise that when corners of American society become dominated by one ideological group, they start to see dissenters from orthodoxy with deep suspicion.
65% : In order to make things a little easier, it would be wise to heed the counsel of psychologist Jonathan Haidt, who says we should "give less offense" by being more polite and "take less offense" by charitably interpreting other's statements and offering forgiveness when we screw up.
63% : Interestingly, the only group where a majority of people do not hold that view is among strong liberals - the most left-wing segment of the public.
63% : We can, for instance, witness hundreds of professors and graduate students signing a letter denouncing the liberal psychologist Steven Pinker for some mild dissents from some of the assertions common in the Black Lives Matter movement (namely that race is the variable most strongly correlated with police shootings).
59% : If our ancestors were paralyzed from speaking in favor of causes that were unpopular, we wouldn't have all kinds of advances from women's suffrage to civil rights.
55% : Pluralistic ignorance is a situation where members of a group may privately reject an idea, but they believe most of the other members of the group believe that idea, so they decide to accept it.
53% : One survey found that by 2014, for instance, the ratio of liberals to conservatives at American colleges and universities was six to one; among New England's institutions of higher education, it's 28 to one.
51% : And still, 42 percent of them say that they self-censor in the same fashion.
49% : Even more worrying than the general climate of fear are the lengths with which some Americans are willing to go to punish their political opponents.
48% : In fact, nearly every ideological grouping believes they have to self-censor, with 52 percent of liberals, 64 percent of moderates and 77 percent of conservatives agreeing that the current political climate prevents them from saying things they believe.
47% : This suggests that self-censorship is now the norm for much of the American public, across ideological lines, with perhaps the most liberal American citizens having a little less fear of speaking their minds than the rest of us.
46% : This includes a quarter of Democrats and a whopping 60 percent of Republicans.
39% : This sentiment is most common among Republicans, with 77 percent agreeing that they are fearful of sharing some of their political views, but majorities of Democrats (52 percent) and independents (59 percent) share the same view.
36% : It found that 62 percent of Americans say they have political views they are afraid to share.
34% : That would be a reasonable enough worry if you're part of the tiny sliver of Americans who works in explicitly political organizations, like a think tank or a campaign, but the number suggests that people who work jobs totally unrelated to politics still fear that their views could cost them their employment.
28% : That last bit of information may be no surprise if you're familiar with some statistics about how liberal-leaning some American institutions have become.
24% : Running an entire country on pluralistic ignorance would prevent us from addressing the actual concerns members of the public have.
23% : It's not that most of these people are bomb-throwing radicals, but many seem to think the country is so polarized that nothing good can come from voicing their own opinion.
19% : Pinker is a rich and famous man who will likely escape any attempt at censorship thrown at him, but what should worry us more is the lowly graduate assistant or professor without tenure who worries that publishing an objective research finding will get them in hot water with their university if its results don't confirm the ideological priors of whatever group happens to be hegemonic in the culture.
18% : Meanwhile, 32 percent of Americans, about a third of the country, worries that their political views could harm their employment.
13% : In order to address this climate of fear, we have to stop being afraid.

*Our bias meter rating uses data science including sentiment analysis, machine learning and our proprietary algorithm for determining biases in news articles. The rating is an independent analysis and is not affiliated nor sponsored by the news source or any other organization

Share via
Copy link
Powered by Social Snap